It is one of those sayings that does not invite challenge.
In that sense, it is similar to the sentence in Robert Frost’s Poem the Mending Wall: Good Fences Make Good Neighbours.
And yet, when we lived in Toronto in the late 1980s – everyone had a fence, but no one knew their neighbour.
Moving next to Prince Edward Island, we found no fences and yet everyone knew their neighbour.
So maybe … just maybe, ‘good fences do not make good neighbours’.
But of course we are not talking about fences – rather today’s topic is Bigger is Better. As in the need for more immigration.
I just listened an Expert on a local talk show waxing on about Canada’s “desperate need for immigration” because our birth rate is below replacement value. “We need immigration if we hope to continue to see our population grow” said he.
But Why, I ask myself, do we need to grow a bigger population? Presumably the day will come when all of earth’s women will not have a sufficient number of babies to sustain population growth.
What then – do we just all shrivel up and die?
The Day’s Expert went on to say that with a growing population we would need more doctors, nurses, engineers and the like. And he pointed out that this would lead to a need for even more immigration. The guy was beside himself with delight at the sound of his words.
But for me the reverse of his statement would also be true - with less immigration – i.e. less growth, Canada’s need for more more professionals would lessen.
Would it not?
The Expert went on to state that Canada currently has a critical need for “skilled workers” and again pointed to increased immigration as the magic wand to rectify this deficiency.
But here too I got to thinking; what about our own workforce. Currently only 60% of working age are employed. Unemployment is especially chronic amongst our young where nearly 15% unemployment is the norm – twice the national figure for all of working age.
So why not make a greater effort to train our own citizens and provide them with the skills our society so desperately needs? They would benefit along with our society.
Fences may indeed not result in better neighbours and Immigration may not result in a better society.
They may well do … but I would be much happier if these …what I term …Rhetorical Assertions … were at least challenged to endeavour to determine the real truth behind them.
As I see it …
“K.D. Galagher’